New Restaurants Coming to Venice and Sarasota Fall 2026 | Julie Papagni
Local Life

New Restaurants Coming to Venice and Sarasota This Fall

· 6 min read
Elegant modern Mexican restaurant interior with a tequila bar, indoor-outdoor patio with palms, and warm evening lighting

The dining scene on the Gulf Coast keeps getting better, and fall 2026 is no exception. The most exciting new arrivals are landing in Venice and Wellen Park, with a few welcome surprises closer to Sarasota and Siesta Key. Whether you are a food lover considering the move or a new resident building your list of go-to spots, here is what is coming to your table this season.

Agave Bandido: A New Chapter in Wellen Park

The Mexican concept Agave Bandido opened its fifth location at 19830 West Villages Parkway in Wellen Park on September 1, 2026. Designed as an indoor-outdoor experience, it pairs a spacious patio with a tequila bar and a menu built around fresh, bold flavors. For residents of Wellen Park and the growing Venice corridor, it brings a polished, event-driven dining room right to the heart of the community, the kind of place you can visit on a Friday night or take guests when they come to see your new home.

Whit's Frozen Custard Lands on Siesta Key

Over toward the islands, Whit's Frozen Custard opened on Siesta Key, a locally owned custard shop that has quickly earned a spot in the September dining conversation. Siesta Key is best known for its beach, but the village is quietly building a lively food scene, and a walkable frozen-custard stop fits it perfectly. It is a lovely little addition for families and for anyone who believes a day at the beach should end with a sweet treat.

Texas Roadhouse: A Return Worth Watching

One of the most anticipated stories of the fall is the possibility of Texas Roadhouse returning to Sarasota County. The steakhouse chain was announced in June 2026 as being considered for the developing Venice Crossing Commercial Center in north Venice. As of now it is still in the planning and announcement stage, not yet open, but the prospect has local families excited, since they currently drive to Sarasota or Fort Myers for that experience. I will keep you updated as plans firm up.

The Venice Dining Scene Is Maturing

What excites me most is the pattern behind all of this. Venice and Wellen Park are no longer just residential communities; they are becoming destinations in their own right, with a dining scene that keeps pace with the luxury homes being built around them. When I work with buyers, the strength of the local food scene is one of the quieter things that makes a neighborhood feel like home, and Venice has it in spades right now.

Whether you are moving here full-time or looking for a second home, I would love to share my favorite dining spots and show you the neighborhoods where they are taking root. Send me a note and let us explore the Gulf Coast, one great meal at a time.

Julie Papagni

Julie Papagni

Broker Associate, eXp Realty · 24 Years Experience